The Problem with Avatar and Cultural Appropriation: Why Diversity in Hollywood Matters

The Problem with Avatar and Cultural Appropriation: Why Diversity in Hollywood Matters

The film industry has long been criticized for its lack of diversity, both in front of and behind the camera. From tokenism to outright whitewashing, Hollywood has been repeatedly called out for failing to accurately represent marginalized communities. One movie that received particular scrutiny was 2009’s Avatar, directed by James Cameron.

On the surface, Avatar’s plot appears to be a classic tale of good versus evil. The story follows a disabled Marine named Jake Sully who is sent to a distant planet called Pandora, inhabited by a fictional Indigenous tribe called the Na’vi. Sully is tasked with infiltrating the Na’vi community and earning their trust in order to aid a mining operation seeking to exploit the planet’s resources. The film garnered critical and commercial success, eventually becoming the highest-grossing movie of all time.

However, beneath the surface, Avatar’s narrative raises a number of concerns about cultural appropriation. The plot relies heavily on colonialist tropes, positioning the Na’vi as primitive and in need of “civilizing” by white outsiders. The movie also borrows heavily from a range of Indigenous cultures, such as the Navajo and Maori, without giving proper credit or respect to those traditions.

This type of cultural appropriation is not unique to Avatar, nor is it limited to Native communities. Hollywood has a long history of taking elements from various cultures and twisting them to fit a white, Western narrative. From Mickey Rooney’s blatantly racist portrayal of a Japanese man in Breakfast at Tiffany’s to Emma Stone’s portrayal of a half-Asian character in Aloha, the entertainment industry has repeatedly failed to accurately represent marginalized communities.

So why does diversity in Hollywood matter? For one, it’s simply good business. High-grossing films with diverse casts, such as Black Panther and Crazy Rich Asians, have proven that audiences are hungry for stories featuring characters from a range of backgrounds. In addition, accurate representation in media can help break down harmful stereotypes and promote understanding and empathy between different communities.

Moreover, diversity in Hollywood is important for young people who are looking for role models and finding their place in the world. When marginalized communities are not represented in media, it sends a message that their stories are not important and that they do not belong. This type of erasure can be incredibly damaging, particularly for young people who are still in the process of forming their identities.

In conclusion, Avatar and other Hollywood films that appropriate elements from marginalized cultures demonstrate how damaging the lack of diversity in the entertainment industry can be. Accurate representation is not only necessary for marginalized communities to see themselves reflected in media, but also for promoting empathy and understanding between different groups. It’s time for Hollywood to take steps towards greater diversity in all facets of the industry, from casting to screenwriting to behind-the-scenes roles.

Speech tips:

Please note that any statements involving politics will not be approved.